GOODYEAR — A Maricopa County judge has rejected a bid by Germayne and Lisa Cunningham to have the murder case over their 7-year-old daughter’s 2017 death dismissed for good, clearing the way for a new trial, ABC15 reported.
The couple faces a long list of charges, including first-degree murder. Their first trial was halted after more than five months when it came to light that Goodyear police had mishandled key evidence and kept the problem secret, according to ABC15, which had reported that police could not prove chain of custody going back years.
Judge Patricia Starr declared a mistrial in April 2026. The defense then asked for the case to be thrown out, leading to a lengthy evidentiary hearing where Goodyear evidence workers and the lead detective testified.
In her new ruling, Starr found that Goodyear police knew about problems with their records system well before trial but did not disclose them. She blamed the police department, not prosecutors.
“Here, the court finds that the prosecutors did not engage in misconduct, let alone misconduct that was intentional and known to be improper and prejudicial,” Starr wrote.
Because the Cunninghams now have the information that was withheld, Starr ruled they can be retried and raise those issues before a new jury, including challenging the chain of custody and the state’s witnesses.
Both defendants were released from custody while the dispute played out. Their retrial is set for April 2027, though that date could change, according to ABC15.
Sources: ABC15. Thee Arizona Times uses AI-assisted reporting reviewed against the sources listed.
Photo: Joe Gratz / CC0 via Wikimedia Commons.